Skip to content
HaulCaptainFLEET DISPATCH DESK

Per-mile pay vs percentage pay, hourly or salary: choosing how your drivers get paid

By Edwin Horton, Truck dispatcher · Updated

Per-mile pay vs percentage pay is the first pay question most owners face when they hire a driver, and hourly and salary aren't far behind. The usual comparison lists pros and cons. A more useful way to look at it: every pay model decides who absorbs three risks, low rates, waiting time and empty miles. Move a risk onto the driver and they'll feel it in a bad week. Feel it often enough, and they leave.

Below: the four models, the same week paid four ways, then a bad week, and what the research on driver turnover says. Payroll mechanics (withholding, settlements, records) are in our trucking payroll guide.

Who carries which risk

Pay modelLow ratesWaiting at docksEmpty milesBest fit
Per mile (all miles)CarrierDriver, unless detention is paidCarrierOver-the-road truckload
Per mile (loaded only)CarrierDriverDriverRarely a good idea
Percentage of linehaulShared with the driverDriver, unless detention is sharedDriver earns nothing on themLeased owner-operators, some regional fleets
HourlyCarrierCarrierCarrierLocal and regional, many stops
Salary or weekly guaranteeCarrierCarrierCarrierDedicated routes with steady volume

Most fleets use a hybrid: a base model plus stop pay, detention pay, layover pay and a weekly minimum. The base decides the culture; the extras patch its gaps.

The same week, paid four ways

EXAMPLE A company driver runs three loads in a week: 2,300 loaded miles, 300 empty miles, $6,440 of linehaul revenue ($2.80 per loaded mile) and 62 hours on duty, 9 of them waiting at docks. Rates are set so all four models pay about the same in this normal week.

ModelMathDriver's week
Per mile, all miles2,600 × $0.62$1,612
Percentage25% × $6,440$1,610
Hourly62 × $26$1,612
Weekly salaryFlat$1,600

Now a bad week

Same driver, same miles, but rates fall to $2.30 per loaded mile and one receiver holds the truck for 12 extra hours.

ModelMathDriver's weekChange
Per mile, all miles2,600 × $0.62$1,612None; the carrier ate the rate drop
Percentage25% × $5,290$1,322.50−$289.50; the driver shared the rate drop
Hourly74 × $26$1,924+$312; the carrier paid for the wait
Weekly salaryFlat$1,600None

Nothing about the driver's work got easier in the bad week. Under percentage pay their check fell 18%. Under hourly pay the carrier's cost rose 19%. That's the risk allocation from the table, in dollars.

What the research says about pay and turnover

ATRI's carriers reported driver turnover of 44.2% in 2025, down from 48% in 2024Driver turnover, ATRI respondents44.2% in 2025, down from 48% in 2024Industry-average truck driver turnover among carriers responding to ATRI's 2026 Analysis of the Operational Costs of Trucking (2025 data), as reported in trade coverage of the report (HDT/Truckinginfo and FreightWaves, July 2026). ATRI respondents are for-hire carriers of many sizes; the figure is not split by fleet size in that coverage.ATRI, Analysis of the Operational Costs of Trucking: 2026 Update, 2025Checked Oct 2026 on average. The National Academies' 2024 study of long-distance trucking found pay level and variability, unpaid time and the amount and predictability of home time were the top reasons drivers leave; higher piece rates were associated with lower turnover, and drivers assigned to one shipper for a long time left less often than randomly dispatched drivers at the same pay What drives turnover (National Academies)Pay level and variability, unpaid time, and the amount and predictability of home timeNational Academies (2024), chapter 3: human resource firms cited put pay (level, variability, unpaid time) and time at home (amount and variability) as the top reasons drivers leave; drivers assigned to one shipper for a long period leave at lower rates than randomly dispatched drivers at the same pay; higher piece rates are associated with lower turnover; referral hires appear less likely to leave.National Academies (2024), Pay and Working Conditions in the Long-Distance Truck and Bus Industries, ch. 3, 2024Checked Oct 2026.

Read that against the risk table: models that push waiting and rate swings onto the driver create exactly the variability and unpaid time drivers say they leave over. Our opinion: if you pay by the mile or by percentage, pay detention and add a weekly minimum. It costs you only in the weeks you didn't keep the truck moving. Our truck driver turnover rate page shows what a lost driver costs.

Rules that touch the pay model

  • Overtime. Interstate drivers under DOT hours-of-service rules are generally exempt from federal overtime, with a catch in weeks involving vehicles of 10,000 lb or less Motor carrier overtime exemption (FLSA 13(b)(1))Interstate drivers under DOT hours-of-service authority are exempt from FLSA overtime; vehicles of 10,000 lb or less bring overtime backDOL Fact Sheet #19: section 13(b)(1) exempts from overtime employees of motor carriers whose duties affect the safety of operation of vehicles in interstate commerce and who fall under DOT's hours-of-service authority. It is an overtime exemption only. In any workweek where the employee's work involves vehicles of 10,000 lb or less (with listed exceptions), overtime applies. State wage laws may differ.U.S. DOL, Fact Sheet #19Checked Oct 2026. Hourly pay doesn't automatically mean overtime pay, but check state law.
  • Leased owner-operators on percentage pay must get a copy of the rated freight bill for each load Truth-in-leasing lease contentsWritten lease: compensation, chargebacks, escrow, insurance, pay within 15 days, freight bill copies49 CFR 376.12: the lease gives the authorized carrier exclusive possession and control of the equipment for its term (c)(1), states the compensation (d), lists every chargeback and how it is computed (h), sets escrow terms with return within 45 days of termination (k), addresses insurance (j), requires payment within 15 days of submitting delivery paperwork (f), and, when pay is a percentage of revenue, a copy of the rated freight bill (g).49 CFR 376.12Checked Oct 2026. Showing company drivers the same number builds trust too, though no federal rule requires it.
  • Minimum wage still applies to employee drivers. A per-mile driver stuck at a dock all week can fall below it for that week's hours.

Choosing a model for your first drivers

  1. Match the freight. Long runs fit per mile; many short stops fit hourly; one steady customer fits salary.
  2. Price it from your numbers. Use the truck driver pay calculator to compare models on your own lanes and miles.
  3. Write the extras down: detention after how many hours, stop pay, layover, breakdown pay, weekly minimum.
  4. Pick a mileage source for per-mile pay (practical route miles or shortest route miles from your routing tool) and say which in the pay policy.
  5. Test a bad week before you offer it. If the driver's check falls more than you'd accept yourself, add a floor.
  6. Keep it simple enough to check. A driver who can recompute their check trusts it.

Paying for work that isn't driving

Whatever the base model, the extras decide whether a hard week feels fair:

  • Detention pay after a set number of hours at a shipper or receiver.
  • Stop pay for each extra pickup or delivery on multi-stop loads.
  • Layover pay when a load leaves the driver stuck overnight away from home.
  • Breakdown pay for time lost to a truck problem the driver didn't cause.
  • Tarp pay on flatbed and step deck loads that need tarping.
  • Training and orientation pay for the first days on the job.

Tie each extra to a record the driver can see, such as check-in and check-out times, so nobody has to argue about it.

Changing the pay model for drivers you already have

Switching a working driver from one model to another is where fleets lose people, even when the new model is fair. A safer way:

  1. Show the math first. Run the last eight weeks of each driver's loads through both models and hand them the comparison.
  2. Protect the average. If anyone would have earned less, add a floor or adjust the rate until they wouldn't.
  3. Start on a pay period boundary, with the change in writing.
  4. Review after a month and fix anything that surprised either side.

Team drivers

Teams add a question solo pay doesn't: how to split. Many teams are paid per mile for the truck's miles and split evenly; others split by who drove. Write the rule down before the first trip. The team driver pay split calculator compares the common splits.

Pay and dispatch

Pay models and dispatch decisions are tied together. A per-mile driver loses money every hour a truck waits; a percentage driver loses money every time a load is booked cheap. Whichever you choose, rate negotiation and reload planning protect the driver's week as much as yours. Our dispatch rates page shows what that service costs, and more people guides are in the playbooks library.

This page is general information, not legal, tax or HR advice.

Driver pay models: common questions

01

Is percentage pay better than per-mile pay for truck drivers?

Neither is better everywhere. Percentage pay rises and falls with the load's rate, so drivers earn more on strong freight and less in a soft market. Per-mile pay is steadier for the driver but leaves the carrier carrying rate risk. Many fleets use per mile for company drivers and percentage for leased owner-operators.

02

What percentage do company drivers usually get?

There's no standard figure we can source. Set it from your own numbers: what percentage of typical linehaul revenue matches the per-mile pay you'd otherwise offer, then test it against a slow week as well as a good one.

03

Should truck drivers be paid for empty miles?

Most per-mile drivers expect to be, and paying loaded miles only pushes the cost of deadhead onto the driver, which shows up in turnover. If you pay loaded miles only, the rate per mile has to be higher to match.

04

Do hourly truck drivers get overtime?

Interstate drivers under DOT hours-of-service rules are generally exempt from federal overtime under FLSA section 13(b)(1), but in weeks when their work involves vehicles of 10,000 lb or less overtime can apply, and some states have their own rules. Check with a payroll professional.

05

How often should I review driver pay?

At least once a year, and whenever your freight changes: new lanes, more waiting, a new customer with many stops. Compare what drivers actually earned per hour on duty with local job offers, and ask the drivers you want to keep what would make them stay.

06

What is a weekly guarantee?

A minimum the driver earns in a week they're available to work, whatever the miles. It protects drivers in slow weeks and costs the carrier only when the truck doesn't run, which gives the carrier a reason to keep it loaded.

SOURCES CITED ON THIS PAGE

DESK OPEN 24/7

Every pay model pays more when the truck runs

Our desk plans the reload before delivery and logs detention as it happens, so drivers on any pay model wait less. You approve every load.

4% for 2+ trucks, 5% for one, 7% while your MC is new